Updated on
January 31, 2025
No items found.
No items found.

Essential Mascara

This brand will send you a refill if you hold onto the wand (or you can buy another wand, too!). Very conscious packaging

Limitless Lash Mascara

Ilia did a Lifecycle Assessment (LCA for those who want to sound cool) and their mono-material tube reduces carbon emissions by 48% and waste by up to 20% compared to another material

Levitation Lash

Won Cosmopolitan's 2024 Holy Grail Beauty Award for Best Lengthening Mascara, this uses 94% post-consumer recycled packaging and uses a bio-fiber brush made from castor plant-derived polymers.

Peptide Lengthening Mascara

This company is serious about mascara and you can get new refills, saving as much as 50% of plastic waste

Liquid Lash Extensions Mascara

Truly the best mascara Lizzie has ever tried (and she's gone through a LOT), this tubing mascara looks phenomenal, and your purchase goes towards supporting work in cancer, domestic abuse, homelesssness & poverty, and so much more.

The Mascara

Low waste, glass vial, refillable. Need we say more?

Find out which How to Choose Mascara Without Harmful Chemicals are better than the rest.

Join today to get access to product recommendations,
unlimited articles, and exclusive weekly content.

$5/month
GET MONTHLY
$50/year
(16% discount)
GET annual

Already a member? Log in.

Choose Wisely with Finch

Access unlimited articles
Find the best products and get expert advice in our independently-reviewed guides
Stay in-the-know with weekly newsletters
Cancel anytime

Learn more about our sources and methodology

LEARN MORE